wait and see

For months, I’ve been bewildered by the level of responses, emotional and civil disobediently, to what’s occurred in the last 2 years some of which Emily Bazelon wrote in the NYT last week about, finishing on this not-rhetorical question:

“The midterms opened up people’s imaginations,” Scheppele said. “There’s a horizon you can see beyond now. But we’ve just taken the first step. What comes out of the rubble, and how do people respond?”

I feel concern about the masses of people, the imaginative bloc (rather than a voting bloc) that purports that this is simply another oscillation of the pendulum of who has governing power. As Astra Taylor wrote in 2019 in Democracy May Not Exist, But We’ll Miss It When It’s Gone:

Democracy destabilizes its own legitimacy and purpose by design, subjecting its core components to continual examination and scrutiny. (page 2)

This has been a decade of instability. I suppose what’s animated me is the simple pair of questions of Who benefits from an action, event or change? and Who loses or suffers from that same action, event or change? And the fallacy of anything in life returning to what it used to be is a way that I listen when someone tells me who they are based on which histories they adhere to, the episodes that they connect to current struggles for power whether the rural populists and farmers opposing the banks of the early 1900s or how communities fought for human rights and civil rights refusing to be collateral damage in a purported democracy that has excluded wide swaths of people since the outset.

There’s a lot of rubble this decade, like every decade, and we can live in haste not reckoning with the destruction or figure out how to do so with different proportions or ways than before. There’s only so many minutes in a day, dollars in a budget, and years in a life so opportunity costs are a fixture. Yet, we must choose.